Law exam technique: how to answer problem questions with IRAC, worked through
Understand IRAC, follow a worked contract problem, plan your timing for a 3-hour paper and practise with three scenarios.
On this page
Good law exam technique comes down to one habit: for every issue in the question, state the legal rule, then apply it to the facts you've been given. IRAC (Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion) is the simplest way to build that habit, and it works for almost every problem question on an LLB paper. Below you'll find a contract problem answered in full with IRAC, the same paragraph written at 2:2 and at first-class level, how essay questions differ, a timing plan for a 3-hour paper and three scenarios to practise on.
What is IRAC in a law exam, and when do you use it?
IRAC stands for Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion. You may also see IPAC (Principle instead of Rule) or ILAC (Law). They're the same method. The Open University's problem question tips suggest repeating it for each party and each possible claim.
Use it for problem questions, where you're given a set of facts and asked to advise someone. For each issue:
- Issue: name the legal question in one sentence, using the facts. "Did Tom's email end Priya's offer?"
- Rule: state the law in your own words, with the case or statute that sets it.
- Application: match the facts to the rule. This is where most of the marks are. If the facts could go either way, argue both.
- Conclusion: answer the issue, and say how confident you are.
Think of IRAC as a loop you run once per issue, not four headings for the whole answer. Answers that write one long "Rule" section and then one long "Application" section lose the link between the law and the facts, which is the thing examiners are marking.
To plan in the exam room, download the IRAC planning sheet and practise filling it in under time.
Worked contract problem question: answered with IRAC
Here's a typical first-year contract question on offer and acceptance.
Worked example (25 marks)
On Monday, Priya emails Tom: "I'll sell you my 1972 Raleigh Chopper for £800. Reply by post by Friday. I'll keep the offer open until then." On Tuesday, Tom emails back: "Would you take £700?" Priya doesn't reply. At 9am on Wednesday, Tom posts a letter: "I accept your offer of £800." At 2pm on Wednesday, Priya sells the bike to Sam for £900 and posts a letter to Tom withdrawing her offer. Priya's letter reaches Tom on Thursday. Tom's letter reaches Priya on Friday. Advise Tom.
Step 1: spot the issues with a timeline
Read the question twice. Then put every communication on a timeline, because in offer and acceptance questions the dates usually are the issues.
| Day | What happened | Issue it raises |
|---|---|---|
| Monday | Priya emails £800 offer | Is it an offer? |
| Tuesday | "Would you take £700?" | Counter-offer or enquiry? |
| Wed 9am | Tom posts acceptance | Postal rule |
| Wed 2pm | Sale to Sam, withdrawal posted | Revocation |
| Thursday | Withdrawal reaches Tom | When revocation works |
| Friday | Acceptance reaches Priya | Was the deadline met? |
Source: case law on BAILII. Last checked: 17 November 2026.
That gives four issues. Spend more words on the ones that are really in doubt, and only a line or two on the obvious ones.
Step 2: answer each issue with IRAC
Issue 1: was Priya's email an offer? An offer is a definite promise to be bound on set terms once it's accepted. Most adverts are only invitations to treat (Partridge v Crittenden (1968)). Priya's email names the item and the price, says how to accept, and is sent to Tom alone. It's an offer.
Issue 2: did "Would you take £700?" end the offer? A counter-offer rejects the original offer and destroys it. In Hyde v Wrench, a buyer who answered a £1,000 offer by proposing £950 could not later accept the £1,000. A request for information does not end the offer (Stevenson v McLean (1880)).
Tom's message proposes a new price, the same term that decided Hyde. That points to a counter-offer. But it's phrased as a question, and Tom didn't reject the £800. He can argue he was only asking whether Priya would negotiate, which is closer to Stevenson. The test is how a reasonable person in Priya's position would read it. On balance it's probably a counter-offer. If so, Tom's letter is a new offer that Priya never accepted, and there's no contract. Because this is arguable, the answer carries on in the alternative.
Issue 3: if the offer survived, when did Tom accept? Under Adams v Lindsell, a posted acceptance takes effect when it's posted. This applies where post is a reasonable way to reply (Henthorn v Fraser (1892)). The offeror can exclude the rule by insisting on actually receiving the acceptance, as in Holwell Securities v Hughes. Priya asked for a reply by post, so post wasn't just reasonable, it was what she required. "Reply by post by Friday" doesn't insist on receipt. Even if "by Friday" means "arrive by Friday", Tom's letter arrived on Friday. Tom accepted at 9am on Wednesday.
Issue 4: did Priya withdraw in time? An offer can be withdrawn at any time before acceptance, even if the offeror promised to keep it open, unless the offeree paid for that promise (Routledge v Grant (1828)). But a withdrawal only takes effect when it reaches the offeree (Byrne v Van Tienhoven (1880)). A sale to someone else counts only if the offeree learns of it from a reliable source (Dickinson v Dodds (1876)). Priya's promise to wait until Friday didn't bind her. Her letter, though, reached Tom on Thursday, a day after he accepted, and nothing suggests he knew about Sam on Wednesday morning. The withdrawal came too late.
Overall conclusion. Everything turns on Issue 2. If Tom's email was only an enquiry, a contract at £800 was made at 9am on Wednesday, and Priya broke it by selling to Sam. Since Sam has the bike, Tom's claim would be for damages, usually the difference between £800 and the cost of a similar bike. If the email was a counter-offer, there's no contract. Advise Tom that he has an arguable claim, but the stronger reading is against him.
The same point at a 2:2 and at a first
Here's Issue 3 written two ways.
The 2:2 version: "The postal rule comes from Adams v Lindsell, where the defendants offered to sell wool and their letter was misdirected. The court held that acceptance is complete on posting. There are exceptions such as Holwell v Hughes and Entores v Miles Far East. So Tom has accepted."
The first-class version: "Tom accepted at 9am on Wednesday, when he posted his letter. Under Adams v Lindsell a posted acceptance is complete on posting, and post was the method Priya chose. She could have excluded the rule by insisting on receipt, as in Holwell, but 'reply by post by Friday' only asks for a posted reply. Her Thursday withdrawal therefore came too late."
The second version retells no case facts. It names one exception and explains why it doesn't apply here, and it ends on a conclusion about Tom. Entores is about instant communication, which isn't relevant to a posted letter, so it's left out.
Essay questions vs problem questions: how the structure changes
Essay questions ask you to argue, not to advise. You still need authorities, but you organise them around your answer to the question rather than around the facts.
| Problem question | Essay question | |
|---|---|---|
| Your task | Advise a party | Argue a position |
| Structure | IRAC, issue by issue | Thesis, argument, counter-argument |
| Authorities | Cases and statutes as rules | Cases plus academic views |
| Conclusion | Likely outcome per issue | Your answer to the question |
For an essay, state your position in the first paragraph. Give each paragraph one point that backs it up, deal with the best argument against you, and come back to the exact words of the question at the end.
How to time a 3-hour law exam
Split your time by the marks. If every question carries equal marks, take 10 minutes at the start to read the whole paper and choose your questions, and 5 minutes at the end to check your conclusions. That leaves 165 minutes.
| Questions | Time each | Suggested split |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 55 mins | 10 plan, 45 write |
| 4 | About 41 mins | 8 plan, 33 write |
Check the rubric on your own paper, since some papers have questions worth different marks or a set reading time. Planning time isn't wasted time: a timeline and an issue list make the writing faster.
When your time on a question runs out, move on. The first marks on any answer are the easiest to earn, so leaving your last question half done costs more than making your second answer a little shorter.
Law exam technique mistakes that cap answers at a 2:2
At most UK universities a lower second covers marks of 50 to 59%, as in Leeds's marking criteria. Law marking descriptors tend to describe 2:2 problem answers in the same terms: they spot most of the issues but not all of them, and they apply the law only in part. These habits keep answers in that band:
- Writing everything you know about the topic instead of what these facts raise.
- Stating the rule correctly but never connecting it to the parties.
- Retelling the facts of cases at length. One clause is usually enough.
- Missing issues hidden in small details, such as a date, a method of reply or a "by Friday".
- Picking one answer when the facts are ambiguous, instead of arguing it both ways.
- Ending without a conclusion, or with "it depends" and no reasons.
- Advising the wrong party, or forgetting a party the question asks about.
A first-class answer usually does the opposite. It catches the small issues, uses the facts to decide which authority fits, and commits to a reasoned answer.
Law problem questions with answers
Use IRAC for each issue. Plan for 10 minutes, then write for 45 under timed conditions before you open the answer.
Question 1: (25 marks)
FitFuel, a gym, posts on Instagram: "We'll pay £500 to anyone who completes our 30-day Push Plan and still can't do 10 push-ups. We've put £5,000 in a separate account to show we mean it." Leo completes every session and on day 31 can only do 7 push-ups. He emails to claim £500. FitFuel replies that the post was "just marketing" and that Leo never told them he was accepting. Advise Leo.
Answer
- Issue: is the post an offer? Most adverts are invitations to treat (Partridge v Crittenden), but an advert can be a unilateral offer if it's clear and shows an intention to be bound. In Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball the company deposited £1,000 at a bank to show it was serious. FitFuel's set-aside £5,000 does the same job, and the condition is specific and measurable. It's an offer.
- Issue: did Leo need to tell FitFuel he was accepting? In a unilateral contract the offeror can waive notice, and doing the act is the acceptance (Carlill). The wording of the post implies that completing the plan is enough.
- Issue: consideration. Completing 30 days of sessions is the act FitFuel asked for, which is good consideration.
- Conclusion: Leo can probably claim £500.
Marks are often lost by treating the post as an ordinary advert and stopping there. Explain why the deposit changes things.
Question 2: (25 marks)
Kemi agrees to refit Dan's café for £20,000, finished by 1 March. Halfway through, she tells Dan she priced the job too low and may not be able to finish. Dan's lease says he must pay his landlord a penalty if the café isn't open by 1 March, so he promises Kemi an extra £3,000 to finish on time. Kemi finishes on 28 February. Dan refuses to pay the £3,000, saying Kemi only did what she'd already agreed to do. Advise Kemi.
Answer
- Issue: was there consideration for Dan's promise? Doing an existing contractual duty is not normally consideration (Stilk v Myrick).
- But under Williams v Roffey, a promise to pay more for the same work can be enforced if the promisor gets a practical benefit and the promise wasn't obtained by economic duress or fraud.
- Application: Dan avoided his landlord's penalty and the cost of finding a new builder, much like the penalty clause the main contractor faced in Roffey. That is a practical benefit.
- Issue: economic duress. Kemi explained a real difficulty and Dan offered the money himself. She made no threat to walk out unless paid, so duress is unlikely.
- Conclusion: Kemi can probably recover the £3,000.
Marks are often lost by stopping at Stilk and concluding there's no consideration.
Question 3: (25 marks)
Ravi texts Jo: "You can have my laptop for £400. If I don't hear back by Friday, I'll take that as a yes." Jo decides to buy it. She moves £400 into a separate account and tells her flatmate, but doesn't reply to Ravi. On Saturday, Ravi sells the laptop to Ali for £450. Advise Jo.
Answer
- Issue: is the text an offer? It names the item, price and Jo as the buyer, so yes.
- Issue: can silence be acceptance? Acceptance must normally be communicated, and an offeror can't turn silence into acceptance. In Felthouse v Bindley, an uncle's "If I hear no more about him, I consider the horse mine" did not create a contract, even though the nephew meant to sell.
- Application: Jo's decision, the money she moved and what she told her flatmate were never communicated to Ravi.
- Stronger answers note the twist: in Felthouse the offeror was trying to enforce, while here it's the offeree. The rule mainly protects offerees, so you can argue that Ravi, who chose the terms, should be held to them. Current authority still makes a contract unlikely.
- Conclusion: there's probably no contract, so Jo has no claim against Ravi.
To practise more scenarios like these, ask Medly's AI tutor to set you a fresh fact pattern on any topic in your module. Write your answer, then ask which issues you missed and where the next mark is.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best way to revise for law exams?
Write timed answers to past problem questions from your own law school, and keep a one-page summary of the key rules and cases for each topic. Our guide on how to revise your notes shows how to turn notes into something you can test yourself on. Medly can then set you new scenarios to practise applying them.
Is a 2:2 in law good?
A 2:2 is an honours degree and keeps a lot of options open. Some graduate employers ask for a 2:1, so check the entry requirements for any role you're aiming at, such as training contracts at magic circle firms.
What is the hardest exam in law?
There's no official ranking. Students often name land law or equity and trusts, because both depend on technical rules that are easy to misapply under time pressure.
Is IRAC the same as IPAC or ILAC?
Yes. They all mean identify the issue, state the law, apply it to the facts and conclude. Use whichever your lecturers use.
Should I use headings in a law problem answer?
Usually, yes. A short heading for each issue or each party helps the examiner follow you. Check your law school's guidance, since a few prefer continuous prose.