ACCA PM variance analysis: basic, mix and yield, and planning and operational variances, with practice
Understand every PM variance formula, work through mix and yield and planning and operational variances, and practice Section C commentary.
On this page
ACCA PM variance analysis means splitting the gap between budgeted and actual results into variances you can calculate, explain and assign to a manager. This guide covers the basic variance formulas, then works through material mix and yield variances and planning and operational variances with an example of each. It then shows how to write Section C commentary and ends with five practice questions with answers.
What do ACCA PM variance questions test?
Standard costing and variances sit in syllabus area D, Budgeting and control. ACCA's examiner's approach article says all MA variances are assumed knowledge. It also says basic variances are unlikely to make up a whole Section B or Section C question. You're more likely to see them in Section A, or as one part of a longer question.
That leaves the 20-mark Section C questions for the extensions PM adds: mix and yield, planning and operational variances, and the discussion of what the numbers mean. The same article says Section C questions come mainly from syllabus areas C, D and E. It also says you earn follow-on marks for valid discussion of your own figures, even if an earlier calculation was wrong.
| Section | What's in it | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| A | 15 objective test questions | 30 |
| B | 3 case questions of 10 marks | 30 |
| C | 2 questions of 20 marks | 40 |
Source: ACCA examiner's approach and PM Essentials. Last checked: 17 November 2026.
The exam lasts three hours. If you're fitting PM into a wider plan, our paper-by-paper plan shows where it sits.
ACCA PM variance formulas: the basic variances in one table
Every advanced variance builds on these, so learn them until you can write each one without stopping to think. In each formula, a positive answer is favorable (F) and a negative answer is adverse (A). The one exception is idle time, which is always adverse unless the standard already allows for it.
| Variance | Formula | Adverse when |
|---|---|---|
| Sales price | (AP - SP) × units sold | Price below standard |
| Sales volume | (Actual - budget units) × margin | Fewer units sold |
| Sales mix | (Actual mix qty - std mix qty) × margin | More low-margin sales |
| Sales quantity | (Std mix qty - budget qty) × margin | Total sales below budget |
| Material price | (SP - AP) × kg bought | Paid more per kg |
| Material usage | (Std kg - actual kg) × SP | Used more kg |
| Labor rate | (SR - AR) × hours paid | Paid more per hour |
| Idle time | Idle hours × SR | Any unplanned idle time |
| Labor efficiency | (Std hours - hours worked) × SR | Work took longer |
| Variable overhead expenditure | (SR × hours worked) - actual cost | Spent more per hour |
| Variable overhead efficiency | (Std hours - hours worked) × SR | Work took longer |
| Fixed overhead expenditure | Budget - actual cost | Spent over budget |
| Fixed overhead volume | (Actual - budget units) × OAR | Made fewer units |
SP and AP are the standard and actual price. SR and AR are the standard and actual rate. "Std kg" and "std hours" mean the standard allowed for the actual output, and OAR is the standard fixed overhead absorption rate per unit. Margin is standard contribution per unit under marginal costing, or standard profit per unit under absorption costing. The fixed overhead volume variance only exists under absorption costing.
To keep these on one page, download the PM variance formula sheet. It also has the mix and yield and planning and operational steps from this guide.
How to calculate material mix and yield variances
Mix and yield variances split the material usage variance in two when a product uses several materials that can be swapped for each other. The mix variance shows the cost of changing the proportions. The yield variance shows whether the total input produced the output it should have.
ACCA's mix and yield article makes two points worth remembering. Only calculate these variances if the mix can actually be varied. And in a reconciliation, use either the usage variance or mix and yield, never both, or you count the same thing twice.
Worked question
Pell Co makes product Z. The standard for one unit is 6 kg of material X at $5 per kg and 4 kg of material Y at $10 per kg. That's 10 kg of input costing $70, an average of $7 per kg. In March, Pell made 1,000 units using 6,600 kg of X and 3,900 kg of Y, which is 10,500 kg in total.
- Put the actual total input into the standard mix. X is 60% and Y is 40%, so 10,500 kg becomes 6,300 kg of X and 4,200 kg of Y.
- Compare each actual quantity with its standard mix quantity, and value the difference at standard price.
- Work out the standard input for the actual output: 1,000 units × 10 kg = 10,000 kg.
- Value the gap between the actual input and the standard input at the average standard cost of $7 per kg.
| Material | Actual mix | Standard mix | Mix variance |
|---|---|---|---|
| X | 6,600 kg | 6,300 kg | $1,500 A |
| Y | 3,900 kg | 4,200 kg | $3,000 F |
| Total | 10,500 kg | 10,500 kg | $1,500 F |
The yield variance is (10,000 - 10,500) × $7 = $3,500 A. You can check it from the output side: 10,500 kg should have made 1,050 units, but Pell made 1,000. That's 50 units short at a standard cost of $70 each, or $3,500 A.
Mix ($1,500 F) plus yield ($3,500 A) gives a usage variance of $2,000 A. That matches the traditional calculation: X is (6,000 - 6,600) × $5 = $3,000 A, and Y is (4,000 - 3,900) × $10 = $1,000 F.
Read together, the story is clear. Pell switched toward the cheaper material and saved $1,500 on the mix, but the new blend produced less output and cost $3,500 in lost yield. ACCA's article suggests you link the yield variance to the mix change in the exam unless the question gives another cause.
How to calculate planning and operational variances
Planning and operational variances split a variance into two parts. The planning variance is the difference between the original standard and a revised standard that reflects conditions managers couldn't control. The operational variance compares actual results with that revised standard, so it measures how well managers did in the conditions they actually faced.
Worked question
Rowe Co's standard for product P is 3 kg of material N at $8 per kg. After the budget was set, a global shortage pushed the market price of N to $10 per kg for the whole period. Rowe made 2,000 units using 6,300 kg, bought at $9.70 per kg for a total of $61,110.
The traditional price variance is (8.00 - 9.70) × 6,300 = $10,710 A. On its own, that makes the buyer look careless. Splitting it gives a fairer picture.
| Variance | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Planning price | (8.00 - 10.00) × 6,300 | $12,600 A |
| Operational price | (10.00 - 9.70) × 6,300 | $1,890 F |
| Usage | (6,000 - 6,300) × 8.00 | $2,400 A |
| Total | 48,000 - 61,110 | $13,110 A |
The buyer beat the revised market price by $0.30 a kilogram, which is a good result. The $12,600 planning variance came from the shortage, outside the buyer's control. Production used 300 kg more than standard, and that $2,400 usage variance is a separate operational issue to explain.
Study texts differ on whether the usage variance should be valued at the original price ($8) or the revised price ($10). State your method in your workings and keep it consistent.
The same idea works for labor and sales. If a new safety rule means each unit now takes longer, revise the standard hours and split the efficiency variance into planning and operational parts. The sales volume variance splits into a market size variance (planning: the whole market grew or shrank) and a market share variance (operational: did the company win or lose share?). Practice questions 3 and 4 below cover both.
Section C often asks you to discuss the method itself as well. Planning and operational variances are fairer to managers, so they're more likely to accept the results and stay motivated. On the other side, a revised standard can be hard to set objectively, managers may blame poor planning for their own poor performance, and the extra analysis takes time.
How to write variance commentary for Section C
A Section C variance question usually asks what the numbers mean as well as what they are. Strong commentary follows the same pattern for each variance:
- Say what the variance means in plain words, with its size. "$3,500 A" means little. "50 fewer units than the input should have made" means a lot.
- Give a cause taken from the scenario. A generic cause like "inflation" earns less than one the question hints at, such as a new supplier.
- Link variances that could share a cause. Examiners reward this, because it shows you see the business behind the numbers.
- Say who is responsible, and whether they could control it.
- Ask whether the standard itself is still realistic. Out-of-date standards create variances nobody caused.
Here's how that reads for Pell Co: "The favorable mix variance of $1,500 shows production used more of the cheaper material X than the standard mix allows. This appears to have reduced output, since 10,500 kg should have made 1,050 units but only 1,000 were made, giving an adverse yield variance of $3,500. Overall the change in mix cost $2,000. The production manager controls the mix and should explain the change. The company should also check whether quality or customer returns have been affected."
Some links come up again and again:
- Cheaper materials (price F) leading to more waste (usage A) and slower working (labor efficiency A).
- Less experienced, lower-paid staff (rate F) working more slowly (efficiency A) and wasting more material (usage A).
- A price cut (sales price A) winning extra sales (sales volume F).
- Overtime premiums (rate A) paid to catch up after idle time.
Commentary is the hardest part to mark yourself. Write a practice answer and get it marked on Medly AI, so you can see which points earned credit and which need more detail.
Try these questions
Work each question before opening the answer. For more by paper and topic, see our ACCA practice questions post, and track your scores as you go: download the practice log.
Question 1: (4 marks)
Kerr Co's standard labor cost is 3 hours per unit at $14 per hour. In June, Kerr made 800 units. Workers were paid for 2,600 hours at $14.50 per hour, but 100 of those hours were idle because of a machine breakdown. Calculate the labor rate, idle time and labor efficiency variances.
Answer
- Rate variance: (14.00 - 14.50) × 2,600 hours paid = $1,300 A.
- Idle time variance: 100 hours × $14 = $1,400 A.
- Hours worked = 2,600 - 100 = 2,500. Standard hours for actual output = 800 × 3 = 2,400.
- Efficiency variance: (2,400 - 2,500) × $14 = $1,400 A.
- Check: standard cost is 2,400 × $14 = $33,600 and actual cost is 2,600 × $14.50 = $37,700, a total of $4,100 A. That equals $1,300 + $1,400 + $1,400.
Most lost marks come from using hours paid instead of hours worked in the efficiency variance.
Question 2: (6 marks)
Tarn Co makes a product in batches. The standard for one batch is 5 kg of material A at $4 per kg and 5 kg of material B at $8 per kg. In April, Tarn made 400 batches using 2,300 kg of A and 1,900 kg of B. Calculate the material mix and yield variances.
Answer
- Total actual input = 2,300 + 1,900 = 4,200 kg. The standard mix is 50:50, so the standard mix quantities are 2,100 kg of A and 2,100 kg of B.
- Mix variance for A: (2,100 - 2,300) × $4 = $800 A.
- Mix variance for B: (2,100 - 1,900) × $8 = $1,600 F.
- Total mix variance = $1,600 F - $800 A = $800 F.
- Standard input for actual output = 400 × 10 kg = 4,000 kg. Average standard cost = $60 ÷ 10 kg = $6 per kg.
- Yield variance: (4,000 - 4,200) × $6 = $1,200 A.
- Check: the usage variance is (2,000 - 2,300) × $4 = $1,200 A for A and (2,000 - 1,900) × $8 = $800 F for B, so $400 A in total. That equals $800 F + $1,200 A.
Most lost marks come from valuing the yield variance at the wrong price. Use the average standard cost per kg of input.
Question 3: (3 marks)
Vale Co's standard is 2 labor hours per unit at $15 per hour. After the budget was set, a new safety regulation meant each unit realistically takes 2.5 hours. Vale made 1,000 units in 2,400 hours. Calculate the planning and operational labor efficiency variances.
Answer
- Original standard hours = 1,000 × 2 = 2,000. Revised standard hours = 1,000 × 2.5 = 2,500.
- Planning variance: (2,000 - 2,500) × $15 = $7,500 A.
- Operational variance: (2,500 - 2,400) × $15 = $1,500 F.
- Check: the traditional efficiency variance is (2,000 - 2,400) × $15 = $6,000 A, which equals $7,500 A + $1,500 F.
The workforce beat the realistic standard. The adverse result comes from the regulation, not from the workers.
Question 4: (3 marks)
Hale Co budgeted to sell 10,000 units at a standard contribution of $12 per unit, based on a 10% share of a market of 100,000 units. The actual market was 90,000 units, and Hale sold 9,500 units. Calculate the market size and market share variances.
Answer
- Revised budget sales = 10% × 90,000 = 9,000 units.
- Market size variance (planning): (9,000 - 10,000) × $12 = $12,000 A.
- Market share variance (operational): (9,500 - 9,000) × $12 = $6,000 F.
- Check: the traditional sales volume variance is (9,500 - 10,000) × $12 = $6,000 A.
Hale's share rose to about 10.6% (9,500 ÷ 90,000) in a shrinking market, so the sales team did well.
Question 5: (4 marks)
In May, Brook Co switched to a cheaper supplier of fabric. The month's variances were: material price $4,000 F, material usage $6,000 A and labor efficiency $3,000 A. Discuss how these variances might be linked, and who is responsible for them.
Answer
Points that would earn credit:
- The cheaper fabric may be lower quality, causing more waste and rejected units. That would explain the adverse usage variance.
- Poorer fabric may be harder to cut and sew, so staff take longer. That would explain the adverse labor efficiency variance.
- Taken together, the switch cost $5,000 overall ($4,000 F - $6,000 A - $3,000 A), so the saving on price was outweighed.
- The purchasing manager chose the supplier, so the production manager shouldn't be blamed for usage and efficiency problems the fabric caused.
- Brook should investigate before acting, check customer returns, and review whether its standards are still realistic.
When these feel comfortable, practice more PM questions on Medly AI. You can get your answers marked and ask the AI tutor to walk you through any step you're stuck on. If you want to see how PM compares with the other papers, read our list of the hardest ACCA exams.
Frequently asked questions
Is variance analysis tested in ACCA PM Section C?
Yes. Standard costing and variances are in syllabus area D, and ACCA says Section C questions come mainly from areas C, D and E. Basic variances alone are unlikely to fill a whole Section C question, so expect mix and yield variances, planning and operational variances, or a discussion of performance.
Do I need the usage variance as well as mix and yield variances?
No. Mix plus yield equals the usage variance, so ACCA's technical article says to use one or the other. Including both counts the same difference twice.
When should you not calculate mix and yield variances?
When the materials can't be substituted for each other. If the recipe is fixed, a mix variance has no meaning and the usage variance tells the whole story.
What is the difference between a planning variance and an operational variance?
A planning variance compares the original standard with a revised standard that reflects conditions outside managers' control. An operational variance compares actual results with the revised standard, so it shows how managers performed in the conditions they faced.
Which price do I use for the operational usage variance?
Study texts differ: some use the original standard price and others use the revised price. Choose one, state it in your workings, and apply it consistently.
Can I still get commentary marks if my calculations are wrong?
Yes. ACCA's examiner says you earn follow-on marks for valid discussion of your own figures, and you can earn marks for observations drawn from the data in the scenario.