Study tips12 min read

ACCA FM investment appraisal: NPV with tax, inflation and working capital, worked through

Understand the money method, time tax savings correctly and build a full NPV step by step, with practice questions and answers.

Medly Team18 November 2026
On this page

ACCA FM investment appraisal questions ask you to turn a project's forecasts into a net present value (NPV) and explain the decision, usually with the money method: inflate each cash flow at its own rate and discount at the money cost of capital. This guide works through one full NPV with tax, tax-allowable depreciation and working capital, step by step. It also covers the mistakes that cost the most marks and ends with practice questions for you to try.

What ACCA FM investment appraisal questions test

The FM exam lasts three hours and has three sections. ACCA's exam guide describes Section C as two 20-mark constructed response questions, marked by a person. Investment appraisal is one of the three syllabus areas those questions mainly come from, according to the FM syllabus and study guide. The other two are working capital management and business finance.

A typical investment appraisal question gives you a page of data and asks for:

  1. An NPV calculation, usually with inflation, tax and working capital.
  2. Sometimes a second technique, such as IRR, payback or discounted payback.
  3. A written part, for example whether to accept the project, the limits of the forecast or how to assess risk.

Markers give credit when you apply the right method to your own earlier figures. That means a clear layout, with every working labeled, is worth as much as getting each number right.

Money method vs real method: which one ACCA expects

You can deal with inflation in two ways. Both give the same NPV when every cash flow rises at the general rate of inflation. In FM questions they rarely do.

MethodCash flowsDiscount rateUse it when
Money (nominal)Inflated at each item's own rateMoney cost of capitalRates differ, or there's tax
RealIn today's pricesReal cost of capitalOne general rate and no tax

Source: ACCA, Advanced investment appraisal and the FM formulae sheet. Last checked: November 17, 2026.

ACCA's technical article says to use the money method as soon as cash flows inflate at different rates. It also applies when a question has both tax and inflation. The reason is tax-allowable depreciation. It is based on what the asset originally cost and doesn't rise with inflation, so you can't simply restate it in today's prices.

To get the money cost of capital, use the Fisher formula from the formulae sheet:

(1 + i) = (1 + r)(1 + h)

Here i is the money rate, r the real rate and h general inflation. With a real rate of 6.8% and general inflation of 3%, 1.068 × 1.03 = 1.10004, so the money cost of capital is 10%.

Keep general and specific inflation apart. A specific rate applies only to the cash flow it's attached to, such as a selling price rising at 4%. The general rate goes into the discount rate, and you also use it for any cash flow that doesn't have a rate of its own.

The real method still saves time in the right question. If there's no tax and everything rises at one general rate, leave the cash flows in today's prices and discount at the real rate.

Tax and tax-allowable depreciation: when the savings arrive

Tax-allowable depreciation (TAD) is the FM name for capital allowances. Each question states the rules, but the usual set-up is:

  • The asset is bought at T0, which is the start of Year 1.
  • The first TAD is claimed against Year 1 profit.
  • If tax is paid one year in arrears, the tax saving on Year 1 TAD arrives at T2.
  • In the final year you get a balancing allowance (tax written-down value minus sale proceeds) or, if proceeds are higher, a balancing charge.

Tax on operating cash flows follows the same timing, so with tax in arrears your table runs one year past the end of the project. If the question says tax is paid in the same year, every tax flow moves back one year. Underline that line when you read the question.

A useful check: total TAD over the asset's life always equals cost minus sale proceeds.

ACCA FM NPV worked example with inflation, tax and working capital

Worked question

Kestrel Co is considering a four-year project.

  • A machine costs $500,000 at the start of Year 1 and will sell for $50,000 (in money terms) at the end of Year 4.
  • Sales are 20,000 units a year at $30 per unit in current prices, rising 4% a year.
  • Variable cost is $14 per unit in current prices, rising 5% a year.
  • Incremental fixed costs are $60,000 a year in current prices, rising 3% a year.
  • Working capital equal to 10% of sales revenue is needed at the start of each year and released at the end.
  • $20,000 has already been spent on market research.
  • Tax is 30%, paid one year in arrears. TAD is 25% reducing balance, with a balancing allowance in the final year.
  • The real cost of capital is 6.8% and general inflation is 3%.

Step 1: find the discount rate

From the Fisher formula above, the money cost of capital is 10%. The $20,000 of research is a sunk cost, so leave it out.

Step 2: inflate the operating cash flows

"Current prices" means today's prices, so Year 1 is inflated once, Year 2 twice and so on. For Year 2:

  1. Sales: 20,000 × $30 × 1.04² = $648,960.
  2. Variable costs: 20,000 × $14 × 1.05² = $308,700.
  3. Fixed costs: $60,000 × 1.03² = $63,654.
  4. Net cash flow: $648,960 − $308,700 − $63,654 = $276,606.
YearSales ($)Total costs ($)Net cash flow ($)
1624,000355,800268,200
2648,960372,354276,606
3674,918389,699285,219
4701,915407,873294,042

Step 3: tax on operating cash flows

Tax at 30% is paid a year later.

Profit yearTax at 30% ($)Paid at
180,460T2
282,982T3
385,566T4
488,213T5

Step 4: tax-allowable depreciation

  1. Year 1: $500,000 × 25% = $125,000, leaving $375,000.
  2. Year 2: $375,000 × 25% = $93,750, leaving $281,250.
  3. Year 3: $281,250 × 25% = $70,313, leaving $210,937.
  4. Year 4 balancing allowance: $210,937 − $50,000 = $160,937.

Total TAD is $450,000, which equals cost minus sale proceeds, so the working checks out.

YearTAD ($)Tax saving ($)Received at
1125,00037,500T2
293,75028,125T3
370,31321,094T4
4160,93748,281T5

Step 5: working capital

Working capital for each year is needed at the start of that year, which is the previous time point. Only the change is a cash flow.

TimeRequirement ($)Cash flow ($)
T062,400(62,400)
T164,896(2,496)
T267,492(2,596)
T370,192(2,700)
T4070,192

The cash flow column sums to zero, so all the working capital has been released.

Step 6: net cash flows and NPV

Each time point brings together:

  • T0: machine (500,000) and working capital (62,400).
  • T1: operating 268,200 and working capital (2,496).
  • T2: operating 276,606, tax (80,460), TAD saving 37,500 and working capital (2,596).
  • T3: operating 285,219, tax (82,982), TAD saving 28,125 and working capital (2,700).
  • T4: operating 294,042, tax (85,566), TAD saving 21,094, sale proceeds 50,000 and working capital released 70,192.
  • T5: tax (88,213) and TAD saving 48,281.
TimeNet cash flow ($)DF at 10%PV ($)
T0(562,400)1.000(562,400)
T1265,7040.909241,525
T2231,0500.826190,847
T3227,6620.751170,974
T4349,7620.683238,887
T5(39,932)0.621(24,798)

The NPV is $255,035. It's positive at Kestrel Co's money cost of capital, so on financial grounds the project should go ahead.

In the exam spreadsheet you'd lay this out across the page, with T0 to T5 as columns and each cash flow type as a row. That layout makes every working easy for the marker to follow.

Common NPV mistakes in ACCA FM

Including sunk costs and financing costs

Only future, incremental cash flows go in the table. That excludes money already spent, such as Kestrel's research, along with allocated head office overheads. Interest costs are also left out because the discount rate already allows for the cost of finance.

Putting Year 0 inside the spreadsheet NPV function

A spreadsheet NPV function treats the first value you give it as a cash flow one year from now. Write =NPV(10%, T1:T5) + T0. If you include T0 inside the brackets, every cash flow is discounted one year too many and your NPV comes out about a tenth too low at 10%. The function uses exact discount factors, so expect small rounding differences from a table-based answer. For more spreadsheet habits that earn marks, see these CBE techniques.

Mixing methods (the hybrid)

The hybrid mixes inflated cash flows with the real discount rate, or the other way round. Take a $110,000 money cash flow at T1. At the 10% money rate it's worth $100,000. At the 6.8% real rate it looks like $102,996, which overstates the project's value. Pick one method and use it for every cash flow and the discount rate.

Treating working capital as a running total

Putting the full requirement into every year counts the same investment several times. Use the year-on-year change, put it one time point early and release it at the end. Working capital doesn't go in the tax rows.

Inflating from the wrong starting year

Check whether figures are given in current prices or Year 1 prices. Current prices are inflated once for Year 1. Figures given in Year 1 prices aren't inflated in Year 1 at all.

When you practice, Medly sets you exam-style FM questions, marks your answers and shows you where each mark went, so you can see whether a slip came from timing, inflation or the method.

Try these questions

Here are four short questions, written at FM level. Work each one before opening the answer.

Question 1: (2 marks)

A company's real cost of capital is 5% and general inflation is expected to be 4% a year. Calculate the money cost of capital.

Answer
  1. Use the Fisher formula: (1 + i) = (1 + r)(1 + h).
  2. (1 + i) = 1.05 × 1.04 = 1.092.
  3. i = 1.092 − 1 = 0.092, so the money cost of capital is 9.2%.

Adding the two rates (9%) loses the mark. Multiply, then subtract 1.

Question 2: (2 marks)

A machine costing $200,000 is bought at the start of Year 1. Tax-allowable depreciation is 25% reducing balance and tax at 30% is paid one year in arrears. Calculate the tax saving from Year 2's tax-allowable depreciation and state when it is received.

Answer
  1. Year 1 TAD: $200,000 × 25% = $50,000, leaving $150,000.
  2. Year 2 TAD: $150,000 × 25% = $37,500.
  3. Tax saving: $37,500 × 30% = $11,250.
  4. Year 2 TAD reduces Year 2 tax, which is paid one year later, so the saving is received at T3.

Most lost marks come from putting this saving at T2.

Question 3: (3 marks)

A three-year project needs working capital equal to 15% of sales revenue, invested at the start of each year and released at the end of the project. Sales revenue is $400,000 in Year 1, $440,000 in Year 2 and $480,000 in Year 3. Calculate the working capital cash flows and state their timing.

Answer
  1. Requirements: 15% × $400,000 = $60,000 (for Year 1), 15% × $440,000 = $66,000 (Year 2), 15% × $480,000 = $72,000 (Year 3).
  2. T0: outflow of $60,000.
  3. T1: outflow of $66,000 − $60,000 = $6,000.
  4. T2: outflow of $72,000 − $66,000 = $6,000.
  5. T3: inflow of $72,000 as all working capital is released.
  6. Check: −60,000 − 6,000 − 6,000 + 72,000 = 0.

Question 4: (2 marks)

A project costs $100,000 at T0 and has net cash inflows of $45,000 at each of T1, T2 and T3. The cost of capital is 10%. A candidate enters =NPV(10%, T0:T3) in the spreadsheet. Explain the error and give the correct formula.

Answer
  1. The NPV function treats its first value as a T1 cash flow, so the $100,000 outlay is discounted for one year and every inflow is discounted one year too many.
  2. The correct formula is =NPV(10%, T1:T3) + T0.
  3. This gives about $11,908 with exact factors. Using the 3-year annuity factor from the tables: $45,000 × 2.487 − $100,000 = $11,915.
  4. The candidate's formula gives about $10,826, which is the correct NPV divided by 1.1.

You'll find more by paper in our ACCA practice questions guide. To keep a printable version of the layout and timing rules beside you, download the NPV proforma. You can then practice more questions like these on Medly, where each answer is marked and explained, and log your scores in the question practice log.

Frequently asked questions

Do I always use the money method in ACCA FM?

Almost always. If the question has tax or cash flows inflating at different rates, use the money method. The real method only fits when everything rises at one general rate and there's no tax.

When is the first tax saving from tax-allowable depreciation received?

With tax paid one year in arrears and the asset bought at T0, the Year 1 saving arrives at T2. If tax is paid in the same year, it arrives at T1.

Is working capital included in the tax calculation?

No. Working capital is a timing difference in cash with no tax effect, so it sits in its own row outside the tax workings.

Should interest costs go into an NPV?

No. The discount rate already reflects the cost of finance, so including interest would count it twice.

How many marks is an NPV question worth in ACCA FM?

Each Section C question is worth 20 marks, and an NPV calculation usually shares the question with other requirements, including a written part. Practice both, because the discussion marks are often the easier ones to pick up. Our guide to the hardest ACCA exams shows where FM sits on pass rates.

How do I calculate IRR in ACCA FM?

Work out the NPV at a second discount rate so you have one positive and one negative NPV, then interpolate: IRR = a + [NPVa ÷ (NPVa − NPVb)] × (b − a), where a and b are the two rates. In the spreadsheet, the IRR function works it out directly, and unlike NPV, its range includes T0.

Does the spreadsheet NPV function give the same answer as discount tables?

Very nearly. The function uses exact discount factors and the tables round to three decimal places, so small differences are normal.

Try Medly for free