ACCA MA absorption vs marginal costing: profit reconciliation worked through, with practice questions
Compare the two profit statements, use the fixed overhead shortcut and work through a two-month reconciliation step by step.
On this page
This guide covers absorption vs marginal costing for ACCA Management Accounting (MA): how each method values inventory, how the two profit statements differ, and how to reconcile one profit to the other. The whole difference comes from fixed production overhead held in inventory, so absorption profit minus marginal profit equals the change in inventory units times the fixed overhead absorption rate. A two-month worked example and four practice questions follow.
Absorption vs marginal costing: what's the difference?
Absorption costing values inventory at full production cost: variable production cost plus an absorbed share of fixed production overhead. Marginal costing values inventory at variable production cost only, and charges all of the period's fixed production overhead as an expense of that period.
Everything else follows from that one choice. Sales revenue is the same under both methods. Selling and administration costs never go into inventory under either.
| Cost | Absorption costing | Marginal costing |
|---|---|---|
| Variable production cost | In inventory | In inventory |
| Fixed production overhead | Absorbed into inventory | Charged in full each period |
| Selling and admin costs | Period cost | Period cost |
| Inventory valued at | Full production cost | Variable production cost |
Because absorption costing carries some fixed overhead forward in closing inventory, the two methods charge that overhead to different periods. No extra cash comes in or goes out. The profit difference is about timing.
Where absorption and marginal costing sit in the ACCA MA exam
The topic is in section C2 of the MA syllabus for September 2026 to June 2027. It asks you to explain the effect of each method on inventory valuation and profit, and to reconcile the profits or losses calculated under the two. Expect it mainly as 2-mark objective test questions. The same idea comes back in section E, where you reconcile budgeted and actual profit under standard absorption and standard marginal costing.
| Part | Questions | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Section A | 35 objective test questions | 70 (2 each) |
| Section B | 3 multi-task questions | 30 (10 each) |
| Time and pass mark | 2 hours, 50% to pass | 100 in total |
Source: ACCA MA essentials and ACCA exams FAQs. Last checked: 19 November 2026.
Absorption and marginal costing profit statements side by side
Both statements start from the same sales figure. They group costs differently on the way to profit.
| Step | Absorption statement | Marginal statement |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sales | Sales |
| 2 | Less production cost of sales at full cost | Less variable production cost of sales |
| 3 | Adjust for under- or over-absorbed overhead | Less variable selling costs |
| 4 | Gross profit | Contribution |
| 5 | Less selling and admin costs | Less actual fixed production overhead and fixed selling and admin |
| 6 | Profit or loss | Profit or loss |
Cost of sales works the same way in both: opening inventory, plus production, less closing inventory. The only change is the value per unit, full production cost in one and variable production cost in the other.
A few points that cost marks:
- Sales revenue and variable selling costs use units sold, not units produced.
- Under-absorbed overhead is added to cost of sales and lowers profit. Over-absorbed overhead is taken off and raises it.
- The marginal statement has no absorption adjustment. It deducts the actual fixed production overhead in full.
- In the absorption statement, don't deduct actual fixed production overhead again below gross profit. It is already in cost of sales, corrected by the absorption adjustment.
- Gross profit and contribution are different subtotals. Gross profit is after production costs; contribution is after all variable costs.
The reconciliation shortcut: change in inventory units times the fixed overhead absorption rate
When opening and closing inventory carry the same fixed overhead per unit, one line gives the difference:
Absorption profit − Marginal profit = (Closing inventory units − Opening inventory units) × Fixed overhead absorption rate per unit
So when inventory rises, absorption profit is higher. When inventory falls, marginal profit is higher. When inventory doesn't change, the two profits are equal.
It works because, under absorption costing, closing inventory carries fixed overhead out of the period and opening inventory brings it in. Medly's lesson on profit reconciliation takes this in four steps: the overhead in each inventory, the sign for each adjustment, the ending result, then a check both ways. The signs depend on where you start:
| Starting from | Opening inventory overhead | Closing inventory overhead |
|---|---|---|
| Marginal profit | Deduct | Add |
| Absorption profit | Add | Deduct |
Two cases need care. If the rate in opening inventory differs from the rate in closing inventory, value each inventory's overhead separately: 100 units at $6 opening and 100 units at $8 closing gives a $200 difference, even though the quantity hasn't changed. And a loss is a negative number. "Higher profit" can mean a smaller loss.
Under- or over-absorbed overhead never enters the reconciliation. It sits inside the absorption statement, but the gap between the two profits is still the overhead held in inventory.
Worked example: a two-month absorption vs marginal costing reconciliation
Hollin Co makes one product. Selling price is $40 a unit and variable production cost is $16 a unit. Fixed production overhead is $60,000 a month, absorbed on budgeted production of 10,000 units a month. Fixed selling and administration costs are $20,000 a month. Hollin Co produces 10,000 units each month, and actual fixed overhead equals the budget. It sells 8,000 units in Month 1 and 11,000 units in Month 2, with no inventory at the start of Month 1.
Step 1: check opening and closing inventory first.
| Units | Month 1 | Month 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Opening inventory | 0 | 2,000 |
| Add production | 10,000 | 10,000 |
| Less sales | (8,000) | (11,000) |
| Closing inventory | 2,000 | 1,000 |
Inventory rises by 2,000 units in Month 1, then falls by 1,000 units in Month 2. Month 1's closing inventory is Month 2's opening inventory.
Step 2: find the absorption rate. $60,000 ÷ 10,000 budgeted units = $6 a unit, so full production cost is $16 + $6 = $22 a unit. Actual production and actual overhead both match the budget, so there is no under- or over-absorption.
Step 3: prepare the marginal costing statements.
| Marginal statement | Month 1 ($) | Month 2 ($) |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | 320,000 | 440,000 |
| Variable cost of sales | (128,000) | (176,000) |
| Contribution | 192,000 | 264,000 |
| Fixed production overhead | (60,000) | (60,000) |
| Fixed selling and admin | (20,000) | (20,000) |
| Profit | 112,000 | 184,000 |
Month 2's variable cost of sales is 2,000 × $16 + 10,000 × $16 − 1,000 × $16 = $32,000 + $160,000 − $16,000 = $176,000.
Step 4: prepare the absorption costing statements.
| Absorption statement | Month 1 ($) | Month 2 ($) |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | 320,000 | 440,000 |
| Opening inventory at $22 | 0 | 44,000 |
| Production at $22 | 220,000 | 220,000 |
| Closing inventory at $22 | (44,000) | (22,000) |
| Cost of sales | (176,000) | (242,000) |
| Gross profit | 144,000 | 198,000 |
| Selling and admin | (20,000) | (20,000) |
| Profit | 124,000 | 178,000 |
Step 5: reconcile and check.
| Reconciliation | Month 1 ($) | Month 2 ($) |
|---|---|---|
| Marginal costing profit | 112,000 | 184,000 |
| Less overhead in opening inventory | 0 | (12,000) |
| Add overhead in closing inventory | 12,000 | 6,000 |
| Absorption costing profit | 124,000 | 178,000 |
The shortcut agrees. Month 1: (2,000 − 0) × $6 = $12,000 higher under absorption. Month 2: (1,000 − 2,000) × $6 = $6,000 lower under absorption.
Over the two months together, marginal profit is $296,000 and absorption profit is $302,000. The $6,000 gap is the 1,000 units still in inventory at $6 each. That overhead is charged when those units are sold.
To keep the layouts and sign rules to hand while you practise, download the reconciliation checklist.
ACCA MA absorption and marginal costing practice questions
These four are Medly questions, from its MA course and its own practice papers, with answers based on Medly's mark schemes. Try each before opening the answer.
Question 1: (2 marks)
Pellet Co operates a municipal recycling facility that produces bags of recycled plastic pellets. Marginal costing profit is $17,600; opening inventory is 600 bags and closing inventory is 1,600 bags. Fixed production overhead is absorbed at $4 per bag.
Which profit would be reported using absorption costing?
A. $13,600
B. $17,600
C. $21,600
D. $24,000
Answer
C. $21,600
- Change in inventory = 1,600 − 600 = 1,000 bags (an increase).
- Fixed overhead adjustment = 1,000 × $4 = $4,000.
- Inventory rose, so absorption profit is higher: $17,600 + $4,000 = $21,600.
A subtracts the $4,000 instead of adding it. B makes no adjustment. D adds $6,400, the overhead in closing inventory alone (1,600 × $4), and forgets the opening inventory.
Question 2: (2 marks)
Navo Co roasts and packs speciality coffee and prepares product profit statements. Its marginal costing profit for the year is $84,000. Opening finished-goods inventory is 1,200 packs and closing inventory is 750 packs. The fixed production overhead absorption rate is $8 per pack throughout the year.
What is Navo Co's absorption costing profit for the year?
A. $78,000
B. $80,400
C. $84,000
D. $87,600
Answer
B. $80,400
- Change in inventory = 750 − 1,200 = a fall of 450 packs.
- Fixed overhead released = 450 × $8 = $3,600.
- Inventory fell, so absorption profit is lower: $84,000 − $3,600 = $80,400.
A subtracts the overhead in closing inventory (750 × $8 = $6,000) rather than the overhead on the fall in inventory. C makes no adjustment. D adds the $3,600, reversing the sign.
Question 3: (2 marks)
Bracken Co is a manufacturing company which produces a single product. The following information relates to October 20X4:
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Opening inventory | 1,000 units |
| Production | 14,000 units |
| Sales | 11,500 units |
| Closing inventory | 3,500 units |
| Variable production cost | $18 per unit |
| Fixed overhead absorption rate | $6 per unit |
The fixed production overhead absorption rate is constant. Marginal costing profit for October 20X4 was $42,000.
Calculate the absorption costing profit for Bracken Co for October 20X4, to the nearest $.
Answer
$57,000 (enter 57000)
- Inventory increase = 3,500 − 1,000 = 2,500 units.
- Profit adjustment = 2,500 × $6 = $15,000.
- Inventory rose, so absorption profit = $42,000 + $15,000 = $57,000.
The variable production cost of $18 isn't needed. Only fixed overhead enters the reconciliation.
Question 4: (2 marks)
Bramley Co manufactures cold-storage systems. For Year 1 profit reporting, opening finished-goods inventory is zero units. Budgeted and actual production are both 16,000 units. Budgeted fixed production overhead is $384,000, absorbed on a per-unit basis. Expected sales are 14,200 units, leaving 1,800 units in closing finished-goods inventory.
Which statement correctly compares Bramley Co's Year 1 divisional profit under absorption costing and marginal costing?
A. Absorption profit equals marginal profit
B. Absorption costing profit is $43,200 higher than marginal costing profit
C. Absorption profit exceeds marginal profit by $48,676
D. Marginal profit exceeds absorption profit by $43,200
Answer
B. Absorption costing profit is $43,200 higher than marginal costing profit.
- Absorption rate = budgeted overhead ÷ budgeted production = $384,000 ÷ 16,000 = $24 per unit.
- Inventory increase = 1,800 − 0 = 1,800 units.
- Overhead carried forward = 1,800 × $24 = $43,200, so absorption profit is $43,200 higher.
A ignores the inventory increase: equal budgeted and actual production doesn't remove it. C divides the overhead by sales (14,200 units) instead of budgeted production. D has the direction the wrong way round.
Medly's ACCA MA course has more questions like these, each marked against Medly's mark scheme, with an AI tutor to talk you through any step you're stuck on. Note which ones you miss in the ACCA question practice log, and for more topics see our ACCA practice questions and CBE techniques. If you're planning the papers after MA, the paper-by-paper plan sets out the order, and the variance analysis guide picks up standard costing at PM level.
Frequently asked questions
Does absorption costing always give a higher profit than marginal costing?
No. Absorption profit is higher only when inventory rises. When inventory falls it is lower, and when inventory is unchanged at the same rate the two profits are equal.
Does under- or over-absorbed overhead change the reconciliation?
No. It appears in the absorption statement, but the gap between the two profits is still the change in inventory units times the absorption rate.
Should the absorption rate use budgeted or actual production?
Budgeted. The rate is set in advance as budgeted fixed production overhead divided by budgeted production. Dividing by sales or actual output is a common wrong option.
Why do the two methods report different profits when the cash is the same?
Because they charge fixed production overhead to different periods. Absorption costing holds some in closing inventory until the goods are sold, so the difference is timing, not extra income or cost.
Which method is used for published financial statements?
Absorption costing. IAS 2 requires inventory cost to include a systematic allocation of fixed production overheads, while marginal costing is used inside the business for decisions.
Is the MA exam changing in 2027?
Yes. Under ACCA's new qualification, MA is replaced by K2 Management Accounting, with exams from July 2027. ACCA has published the K2 syllabus covering July 2027 to August 2028. If you sit from July 2027, check it for your session's topics and format.